Home/Where to stay/Siesta Key/Top-rated hotels
Top-rated hotels in Siesta Key
Twelve four-star places to stay in Siesta Key, ordered by guest score weighted by how many verified stays sit behind it. The scores run from 5.0 down to 4.2, so this shortlist is for travellers who want the best-reviewed addresses on the key rather than the longest list.
Staying in Siesta Key
Siesta Key sits in Florida, and this site lists 46 places to stay on the island, every one of them classed four or five star by the booking supplier. None of the 46 is five star; 15 carry a guest score from verified stays. The twelve below are the best supported of those, with review counts from 49 up to 216 behind their ratings.
The addresses spread along the key's main roads rather than clustering in one spot. Beach Road names two of the stays, Midnight Pass Road runs through several more from 5855 up to 6415, and the rest sit on named lanes such as Derby Lane, Edgemere Lane, Calle De La Siesta, Sun N Sea Drive and Cape Aqua Drive. That spread suits couples and families who want a quieter base with a car, and the larger two-bedroom units at Harbor Towers work for longer stays; short-break travellers should pick by address, since nothing here is a hotel with a front desk and services.
The shortlist
Ranked by guest rating, then number of reviews.
Siesta Key Beach 665 #1
665 Beach Road
Why stay hereA 4-star address right on Beach Road, this is the highest-scoring stay on the list, with a perfect 5.0 guest rating from 100 reviews. Guests consistently rate it at the very top, which makes it a natural pick for travellers who want their Siesta Key base to be the surest bet rather than a gamble. Couples and small groups looking for a polished, well-reviewed place near the sand will find little to argue with here.
See Siesta Key Beach 665 #1The Inn at Turtle Beach
9004 Midnight Pass Rd Sarasota Fl 34242 Usa
Why stay hereSet on Midnight Pass Rd, The Inn at Turtle Beach earns a 4.7 guest rating across 87 reviews, a strong record that puts it among the best-loved 4-star stays in Siesta Key. The name places it at the southern, quieter end of the key, away from the busiest stretch of Beach Road. It suits guests who want a calm, well-regarded base and are happy to be a little removed from the central bustle.
See The Inn at Turtle BeachSiesta Key Miramar 1216
1216 Derby Lane
Why stay hereOn Derby Lane, this 4-star property holds a 4.7 guest rating from 57 reviews. Reviewers are few but enthusiastic, which suggests a stay that quietly delivers rather than shouts. It is a sensible choice for travellers who prefer a residential-feeling street to a resort strip and want a well-rated 4-star base for exploring Siesta Key at their own pace.
See Siesta Key Miramar 1216Central Edgemere 738
738 Edgemere Lane
Why stay hereCentral Edgemere 738 carries the 4-star label and a 4.7 guest rating drawn from 57 reviews. The name points to a central position on the key, convenient for reaching both the beach and the village without committing to either. With that rating behind it, it suits guests who want a dependable, well-reviewed base in the middle of things and are travelling as a couple or small group.
See Central Edgemere 738Walk To the Beach Or Village in Minutes
5304 Calle De La Siesta
Why stay hereThe name says it plainly: this 4-star stay on Calle De La Siesta puts the beach and the village within easy reach, which is exactly what many visitors to Siesta Key come for. A 4.7 guest rating from 55 reviews backs up the location-led appeal. It fits travellers who would rather walk out to the sand or the shops than plan around a car, and who value a compact, highly rated base.
See Walk To the Beach Or Village in MinutesFanta Sea 53 By Beachside Management
53 Beach Road
Why stay hereFanta Sea 53 sits on Beach Road and has built up 216 reviews, the largest review base on this list, with a 4.3 guest rating to show for it. Managed by Beachside Management, it is a 4-star option for guests who like the reassurance of a property many others have already stayed in and rated. Its position on Beach Road keeps the key's main draw close at hand.
See Fanta Sea 53 By Beachside ManagementSun and Sea By Beachside Management
1135 Sun N Sea Drive Unit 1 & 2
Why stay hereAnother Beachside Management property, Sun and Sea occupies 1135 Sun N Sea Drive and holds a 4.3 guest rating from 215 reviews. The volume of feedback makes it one of the more tried-and-tested 4-star choices in Siesta Key. It suits visitors who want a straightforward, well-reviewed stay and are content with a setting slightly off the main Beach Road drag.
See Sun and Sea By Beachside ManagementSiesta Key Beach Cape Aqua 5545
5545 Cape Aqua Drive
Why stay hereSiesta Key Beach Cape Aqua 5545 is a 4-star property on Cape Aqua Drive with a 4.2 guest rating across 209 reviews. The steady stream of reviews points to a popular, well-used stay rather than a newcomer. Travellers who prefer a quieter residential address while still being on Siesta Key, and who want a broadly approved 4-star base, will find it a reasonable fit.
See Siesta Key Beach Cape Aqua 5545Harbor Towers 2nd Fl 2 Bedroom Pool View
5855 Midnight Pass Rd
Why stay hereOn the 2nd floor of Harbor Towers at 5855 Midnight Pass Rd, this 2-bedroom unit is named for its pool view, so the water is part of the stay rather than a trip out. The 4-star property holds a 4.3 guest rating from 50 reviews. The two-bedroom layout and pool setting make it a good match for families or two couples who want space and a place to cool off.
See Harbor Towers 2nd Fl 2 Bedroom Pool ViewHarbor Towers 3rd Fl 2 Bedroom Bay View
5855 Midnight Pass Rd
Why stay hereThe 3rd-floor counterpart at Harbor Towers on Midnight Pass Rd, this 2-bedroom unit is named for its bay view, giving guests something to look out on from higher up. It is a 4-star property rated 4.3 by 50 reviewers. Couples or small groups who want two bedrooms, an elevated outlook and a well-rated base on the key's southern stretch should find it a comfortable choice.
See Harbor Towers 3rd Fl 2 Bedroom Bay ViewHarbor Tower Gulf Luxe Escape
5855 Midnight Pass Rd
Why stay hereHarbor Tower Gulf Luxe Escape shares the 5855 Midnight Pass Rd address and the 4.3 guest rating from 50 reviews, and its name signals a more polished, upscale take on the Harbor Towers stay. It is aimed at guests who want a 4-star base with a touch more finish. Good for travellers treating the trip as a proper escape rather than a quick stop.
See Harbor Tower Gulf Luxe EscapeSiesta Chillin Anchorage 305 Siesta Key
6415 Midnight Pass Road
Why stay hereSiesta Chillin Anchorage 305 Siesta Key is a 4-star property at 6415 Midnight Pass Road with a 4.2 guest rating from 49 reviews. The relaxed name and southern Midnight Pass Road setting suggest a low-key stay, and the solid rating supports it. It suits visitors who want a calm, well-reviewed 4-star base and are happy to be on the quieter end of Siesta Key.
See Siesta Chillin Anchorage 305 Siesta Key
How to choose
For the highest scores
These five carry the strongest guest scores on the list. Siesta Key Beach 665 #1 holds a perfect 5.0 from 100 reviews, the only top mark here. The Inn at Turtle Beach, Siesta Key Miramar 1216, Central Edgemere 738 and Walk To the Beach Or Village in Minutes all sit at 4.7, from 87, 57, 57 and 55 reviews respectively.
Siesta Key Beach 665 #1 · The Inn at Turtle Beach · Siesta Key Miramar 1216 · Central Edgemere 738 · Walk To the Beach Or Village in Minutes
For quieter, smaller stays
Guest review counts of 49 to 57 put these among the least-reviewed but well-scored options: Siesta Key Miramar 1216 and Central Edgemere 738 at 4.7, Walk To the Beach Or Village in Minutes at 4.7, and Siesta Chillin Anchorage 305 Siesta Key at 4.2. Small addresses on lanes rather than the main road.
Siesta Key Miramar 1216 · Central Edgemere 738 · Siesta Chillin Anchorage 305 Siesta Key · Walk To the Beach Or Village in Minutes
Questions, answered
How many places does this site list in Siesta Key?
46, each with its own page. The twelve on this shortlist are the best supported of them, ordered by guest score weighted by how many stays are behind it.
Are any of these hotels five star?
No. Every stay listed in Siesta Key is classed four or five star by the supplier, and 0 of the 46 are five star. All twelve on this shortlist are four star.
Do the guest scores come from real stays?
Yes. Scores come from verified stays, and 15 of the 46 places in Siesta Key carry one. On this shortlist they range from 5.0 at Siesta Key Beach 665 #1 down to 4.2 at Siesta Key Beach Cape Aqua 5545 and Siesta Chillin Anchorage 305 Siesta Key.
Which hotel has the most reviews?
Fanta Sea 53 By Beachside Management on Beach Road, with 216 reviews and a score of 4.3. Sun and Sea By Beachside Management follows with 215 reviews at the same score, and Siesta Key Beach Cape Aqua 5545 has 209 at 4.2.
What facilities do these properties have?
The booking supplier's record for each of these twelve does not list facilities on this page. Star class, guest score, review count and address are what the data gives, so check the individual property page for what is provided.