Home/Where to stay/Key Largo/Top-rated hotels
Top-rated hotels in Key Largo
The 9 highest-scoring four-star stays in Key Largo, drawn from the 46 places this site lists there and ordered by guest score weighted by volume of reviews. All sit on or near the Overseas Highway for a Florida Keys break.
Staying in Key Largo
Key Largo sits in Florida, and this site lists 46 places to stay across the town, every one of them classed four or five star by the supplier, with none at five. The 9 properties below are the ones with a guest score from verified stays, and the list opens on the best supported of those, so each entry here carries real reviews behind it rather than a bare star rating.
Nearly every address runs along the Overseas Highway or off it toward the water: 1500 Ocean Bay Drive, 97501, 103800, 97000, 95490, 97450 and 99010 Overseas Highway, plus Burton Drive in Ocean Pointe Suites. That spread puts the shortlist between the marina-side resorts and the bayside condos, which suits couples after an oceanfront villa, families wanting a resort with a marina, and short-break visitors who would rather stay on the highway and reach the water quickly.
The shortlist
Ranked by guest rating, then number of reviews.
Licensed Mgr Modern Oceanfront Condo Beautiful Ocean Views Beach Resort 2 King Beds
1500 Ocean Bay Drive 402
Why stay hereAn oceanfront condominium at 1500 Ocean Bay Drive 402, run by a licensed manager and laid out around 2 king beds, so two couples or a family travel without arguing over sleeping arrangements. The modern interior and the ocean views are the draw, and guests reward it with a 4.5 rating across 858 reviews. It suits travellers who want the space and independence of a condo with the ocean at the front and a beach resort around them.
See Licensed Mgr Modern Oceanfront Condo Beautiful Ocean Views Beach Resort 2 King BedsMariner's Resort Villas & Marina
97501 Overseas Hwy Key Largo Florida 33037
Why stay hereMariner's Resort Villas & Marina sits at 97501 Overseas Hwy, a 4-star address whose name promises both villa accommodation and a marina setting. A 4.5 rating from 680 reviews puts it among the best-reviewed stays in Key Largo. The villa format works well for guests staying several nights or arriving by water, and the marina location gives the property its own character on the Overseas Highway.
See Mariner's Resort Villas & MarinaReefhouse Resort & Marina
103800 Overseas Hwy
Why stay hereReefhouse Resort & Marina on Overseas Hwy carries a 4-star class and a 4.4 guest rating drawn from 2397 reviews, one of the largest review counts on this list. The combination of resort and marina means boating guests and road travellers are both served, and the volume of feedback gives a reliable picture of what to expect. Suited to visitors who prefer a well-established property with plenty of guest experience behind it.
See Reefhouse Resort & MarinaPlaya Largo Resort & Spa Autograph Collection
97450 Overseas Highway
Why stay herePlaya Largo Resort & Spa Autograph Collection at 97450 Overseas Highway pairs a 4-star class with a spa, so the stay can be built around resting as much as exploring. Its 4.4 rating comes from 2238 reviews. The Autograph Collection badge appeals to travellers who like an independent feel within a recognised group, and the spa is the facility to plan around here, whether for a couple's break or a solo reset.
See Playa Largo Resort & Spa Autograph CollectionPlaya Largo Ocean Residences
Overseas Highway Key Largo Fl 33037
Why stay herePlaya Largo Ocean Residences on Overseas Highway offers a residence-style stay rather than a standard hotel room, with a 4-star class and a 4.4 rating across 2238 reviews. It suits longer stays and guests who want their own base in Key Largo while still being part of a resort setting. Choose it if a residential layout and the Playa Largo name matter more to you than a traditional room.
See Playa Largo Ocean ResidencesBaker's Cay Resort Key Largo Curio Collection by Hilton
97000 Overseas Highway
Why stay hereBaker's Cay Resort Key Largo Curio Collection by Hilton, at 97000 Overseas Highway, is a 4-star resort with the largest review base here at 2669, rated 4.3. The Curio Collection by Hilton name signals a property with its own personality backed by a global group's standards. It fits travellers who want a full resort on the Overseas Highway and value a long, well-documented guest record when choosing where to stay.
See Baker's Cay Resort Key Largo Curio Collection by HiltonBungalows Key Largo
99010 Overseas Highway Key Largo Florida 33037 Us
Why stay hereBungalows Key Largo on 99010 Overseas Highway is built around individual bungalows, which sets it apart from the condo and villa options on this list. The 4-star property holds a 4.2 rating from 923 reviews. Guests who prefer low-rise, separate accommodation over corridors and shared buildings will find the format appealing, and the bungalow layout suits couples wanting privacy during their stay in Key Largo.
See Bungalows Key LargoBennetts Beach Estate
95490 Overseas Highway
Why stay hereBennetts Beach Estate at 95490 Overseas Highway is the smallest property here by review count, with 59 reviews and a 4.1 rating, and its 4-star class marks it as a quality address. The estate format suggests a private, house-like stay rather than a large resort. It suits guests who want space and quiet, and who are comfortable choosing a property on a modest but positive record of guest feedback.
See Bennetts Beach EstateOcean Pointe Suites at Key Largo
500 Burton Drive
Why stay hereOcean Pointe Suites at Key Largo, at 500 Burton Drive, offers suite accommodation with a 4-star class and a 4.0 guest rating from 2083 reviews. The suite format gives families and longer-staying guests room to spread out, and the size of the review base makes the rating meaningful rather than a handful of opinions. A solid choice for travellers who want a suite and a Burton Drive address just off the Overseas Highway.
See Ocean Pointe Suites at Key Largo
How to choose
For resort facilities
Mariner's Resort Villas & Marina, Reefhouse Resort & Marina, Playa Largo Resort & Spa Autograph Collection, Baker's Cay Resort Key Largo Curio Collection by Hilton and Bungalows Key Largo are the five named as resorts, and Reefhouse, Baker's Cay and Playa Largo carry the heaviest review counts on the list at 2397, 2669 and 2238.
Mariner's Resort Villas & Marina · Reefhouse Resort & Marina · Playa Largo Resort & Spa Autograph Collection · Baker's Cay Resort Key Largo Curio Collection by Hilton · Bungalows Key Largo
For oceanfront stays
The Licensed Mgr Modern Oceanfront Condo on Ocean Bay Drive is the one entry whose name states an oceanfront position and ocean views, and it holds 4.5 out of 5 across 858 reviews, level with Mariner's Resort Villas & Marina at the top of the score range.
Licensed Mgr Modern Oceanfront Condo Beautiful Ocean Views Beach Resort 2 King Beds
For the smallest properties
Bennetts Beach Estate has 59 reviews behind its 4.1, Mariner's Resort Villas & Marina 680 behind its 4.5, and the Oceanfront Condo 858 behind its 4.5 — the thinnest review bases on the list, if you prefer a quieter, less heavily booked address.
Bennetts Beach Estate · Mariner's Resort Villas & Marina · Licensed Mgr Modern Oceanfront Condo Beautiful Ocean Views Beach Resort 2 King Beds
For the strongest guest scores
Five properties score 4.4 or better: the Oceanfront Condo and Mariner's Resort Villas & Marina at 4.5, then Reefhouse Resort & Marina, Playa Largo Resort & Spa Autograph Collection and Playa Largo Ocean Residences at 4.4, the last two with 2238 reviews each.
Licensed Mgr Modern Oceanfront Condo Beautiful Ocean Views Beach Resort 2 King Beds · Mariner's Resort Villas & Marina · Reefhouse Resort & Marina · Playa Largo Resort & Spa Autograph Collection · Playa Largo Ocean Residences
Where to stay in Key Largo
Ocean Bay Drive
1500 Ocean Bay Drive is the address of the Licensed Mgr Modern Oceanfront Condo, a 4-star property scored 4.5 out of 5 from 858 reviews and named for ocean views and its beach resort setting — the single entry on this shortlist off the Overseas Highway.
Our picks here: Licensed Mgr Modern Oceanfront Condo Beautiful Ocean Views Beach Resort 2 King Beds
Burton Drive
Ocean Pointe Suites at Key Largo sits at 500 Burton Drive, the lowest-scoring entry here at 4.0 out of 5 but backed by 2083 reviews — the largest guest base among the properties not on the Overseas Highway.
Our picks here: Ocean Pointe Suites at Key Largo
Questions, answered
How many places does this site list in Key Largo?
46, each with its own page. The 9 on this shortlist are the ones carrying a guest score from verified stays, ordered by that score weighted by how many stays sit behind it.
Are any of these hotels five star?
No. Every stay listed in Key Largo is classed four or five star by the supplier, and 0 of them are five star. All 9 properties on this shortlist are 4-star.
Which hotel has the most reviews?
Baker's Cay Resort Key Largo Curio Collection by Hilton has 2669 reviews at 4.3 out of 5, followed by Reefhouse Resort & Marina with 2397 at 4.4 and Playa Largo Resort & Spa Autograph Collection and Playa Largo Ocean Residences at 2238 each.
Which has the fewest?
Bennetts Beach Estate at 95490 Overseas Highway, with 59 reviews and a score of 4.1 out of 5 — well short of the review volume behind the rest of the list.
What is the highest guest score here?
4.5 out of 5, shared by the Licensed Mgr Modern Oceanfront Condo on Ocean Bay Drive (858 reviews) and Mariner's Resort Villas & Marina on Overseas Hwy (680 reviews).
Is this shortlist suitable for a short break?
All 9 are 4-star properties along or just off the Overseas Highway, and every one has a guest score from verified stays, so you can weigh a 59-review estate against a 2669-review resort before choosing.